The blue arc in this Hubble photograph looks like part of the golden galaxy cluster beside it. Its light actually comes from a galaxy far behind the cluster. The gravity of the foreground galaxies bends that light on its way to us, stretching the image of a distant source into an arc. Its shape gives astronomers a way to weigh matter they cannot see. Now imagine looking for one in 68 million pictures. ESA’s original lens gallery

That was the job facing the team behind the Euclid space telescope’s first major data release on November 12. Its survey recorded more than 900 million galaxies over roughly 13 months. The team narrowed the search to 68 million objects, then combined five machine-learning models with the judgment of around 7,000 volunteers and 67 specialists. They came away with 15,072 strong gravitational lens candidates rated highly enough to make the main catalogue. Euclid catalogue paper · Reuters

What the volunteers saw

The models made a first pass over the images. Volunteers working on the Space Warps project then inspected about 300,000 objects, submitting more than 4.5 million classifications between them. Multiple people could look at the same object. By the time the professional lens researchers took their turn, they had a little over 30,000 objects to inspect. That division of labour put far more eyes on the ambiguous cases than any one astronomy team could supply. Euclid methods paper · Oxford’s account

Even experts disagreed about some images, and the team calibrated its grading to account for differences between individual reviewers. The split survives in the published data. Of the 15,072 candidates, 6,073 received the strongest grade and 8,999 were judged probable. An astronomer who needs an especially clear example can begin with the first group. Someone hunting an unusual configuration can take a closer look at the second. Catalogue and grades · Grading method

When a galaxy bends light twice

Among the results are 84 candidates in which one foreground galaxy may bend light from two different galaxies behind it. In the right alignment, that can produce two rings around the same object. Their shapes carry information about the mass doing the bending, including dark matter. The same distortion also magnifies the background sources, allowing astronomers to study distant galaxies that would otherwise be too faint. A reader looking at a blue arc is seeing evidence about two places in the universe at once. Euclid catalogue paper · ESA’s lens gallery