Black Rice Was Harder for This Sushi Robot to Shape
Rice portions judged acceptable or better · One robot hand · 20 fresh attempts with each kind of rice
Each circle is one attempt. Filled circles met the panel’s threshold for shape.
Sources, data and detail
What the figures show
A sushi chef can switch ingredients and adjust by feel. What happens when a robot hand that has practiced shaping rice meets a different variety? Researchers gave TacSushi one job with two kinds of rice. It had to squeeze a portion into an oval that could hold its shape. The hand had cameras and touch sensors at its fingertips for both tests.
With the rice it had practiced on, 15 of its 20 attempts passed. With black rice, an ingredient the team reserved for testing, seven passed. Both counts come from the full model in the researchers’ November 13 workshop report. The broader experiment also included wrapping seaweed and placing toppings.
What counted as a good rice ball? Five people and three AI models scored a photo of each finished portion. An average of at least three on a five-point scale counted as acceptable. This captures what a diner could see on the plate. Taste and texture would require a different test. With just 20 attempts per ingredient, each portion moves the score by five percentage points.
Data and method
20 fresh rice-shaping attempts per ingredient with the full TacSushi model.
| Rice | Successful attempts |
|---|---|
| Familiar rice | 15 / 20 |
| Black rice | 7 / 20 |
Five people and three AI models rated the final image from each attempt. The chart counts portions that averaged at least 3 out of 5.
Sources
7/20black-rice portions passed the robot’s shaping test.
One robot hand · 20 fresh attempts with each kind of rice
Each circle is one attempt. Filled circles met the panel’s threshold for shape.
Source: Hu, Kogashi and Koike-Akino · MERL workshop report, Table 2