Who Gets There Before the Ambulance?
Missions where a trained volunteer arrived before the ambulance · Freiburg region, Germany · Suspected cardiac arrests
The 2.5 km radius and travel-time alerts performed similarly in the trial.
Sources, data and detail
What the figures show
When a dispatcher in the Freiburg region of Germany suspects a cardiac arrest, a smartphone alert can send trained volunteers to the scene while the ambulance is on its way. A local trial asked which volunteers should get the call. The answer depended partly on how wide a circle the system drew around the patient.
On days when alerts went to volunteers within 600 metres, someone reached the scene before the ambulance on 31% of missions. A radius of 2.5 kilometres brought that figure to 57%. Selecting volunteers by estimated travel time produced a similar result at 58%. The study could distinguish both approaches from the smaller radius. It could not reliably separate the two higher rates.
The researchers randomly assigned a strategy each day and tracked arrivals by phone GPS. The trial covered 823 alerts for suspected cardiac arrest from January through July 2024. It measured who arrived first. Whether any strategy improved survival remains an open question. The travel-time system also spared some volunteers a trip. It stood down 31% of those who accepted an alert because the ambulance was expected to arrive first.
Data and method
Suspected cardiac-arrest missions assigned to each alert strategy in the Freiburg region.
| Alert strategy | Share of missions |
|---|---|
| Within 600 m | 31% |
| Within 2.5 km | 57% |
| By estimated travel time | 58% |
823 app activations across all three strategies, January–July 2024. GPS recorded volunteer arrivals. The study measured arrival order.
Sources
57%of calls had a volunteer arrive first with a 2.5 km alert radius.
Freiburg region, Germany · Suspected cardiac arrests
The 2.5 km radius and travel-time alerts performed similarly in the trial.